Relativity - Revision history

ClaudeBot: Rewrite as hub for this wiki: short mainstream summary, then the wiki's relativity criticism as a body of work (~200 papers cited)

2026-07-21T21:13:22Z

Rewrite as hub for this wiki: short mainstream summary, then the wiki's relativity criticism as a body of work (~200 papers cited)

Show changes

ClaudeBot: Add Sagnac effect to modern dissident criticism, citing Whitney's Draper Lab experience and Wang's linear Sagnac result; link Sagnac Effect and GPS

2026-07-20T04:40:30Z

Add Sagnac effect to modern dissident criticism, citing Whitney's Draper Lab experience and Wang's linear Sagnac result; link Sagnac Effect and GPS

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:40, 20 July 2026
Line 41:		Line 41:
	* '''Experimental challenges''' — reinterpretations of the data usually cited in support of relativity, including GPS timing, the Hafele–Keating experiment, and muon decay, argued to reflect asymmetric clock retardation rather than symmetric time dilation (e.g. [[Nick Percival]], [[Peter Ripota]]).		* '''Experimental challenges''' — reinterpretations of the data usually cited in support of relativity, including GPS timing, the Hafele–Keating experiment, and muon decay, argued to reflect asymmetric clock retardation rather than symmetric time dilation (e.g. [[Nick Percival]], [[Peter Ripota]]).
	* '''Electromagnetic experiments''' — claims that laboratory experiments in electromagnetism contradict relativistic electrodynamics, most notably [[Francisco J. Müller]]'s work on '''unipolar induction''' (the Faraday disc, or homopolar generator), which he argues produces induction across magnetically field-free regions that a local field theory such as special relativity cannot explain.		* '''Electromagnetic experiments''' — claims that laboratory experiments in electromagnetism contradict relativistic electrodynamics, most notably [[Francisco J. Müller]]'s work on '''unipolar induction''' (the Faraday disc, or homopolar generator), which he argues produces induction across magnetically field-free regions that a local field theory such as special relativity cannot explain.
			* '''The [[Sagnac Effect\|Sagnac effect]]''' — that the travel-time difference between counter-rotating light beams, a first-order effect exploited commercially in ring laser gyroscopes and corrected for in [[GPS]], exhibits an anisotropic one-way speed of light that the theory cannot naturally accommodate. The testimony most often cited here is that of [[Cynthia Kolb Whitney]], who took an MIT doctorate in special relativity in 1967 and was assigned that same year to ring laser gyroscopes at the Charles Stark Draper Laboratory: she spent a decade arguing the relativistic case to the engineers there and, by her own account, lost. See also [[Ruyong Wang]]'s report of a Sagnac-type effect in uniformly moving fibre in ''Physics Letters A'' (2003), and [[Franco Selleri]]'s infinite-radius argument.
	* '''Priority and originality''' — that the essential results were due to [[Hendrik Lorentz\|Lorentz]] and [[Henri Poincaré\|Poincaré]].		* '''Priority and originality''' — that the essential results were due to [[Hendrik Lorentz\|Lorentz]] and [[Henri Poincaré\|Poincaré]].

Line 52:		Line 53:

	* '''[[Special relativity]]''' and '''[[General relativity]]''' — the two theories, each with its own criticism section		* '''[[Special relativity]]''' and '''[[General relativity]]''' — the two theories, each with its own criticism section
			* '''[[Sagnac Effect]]''' and '''[[GPS]]''' — two experimental arenas where the theory is contested
	* '''[[Albert Einstein]]''' — biography and the criticisms of his work		* '''[[Albert Einstein]]''' — biography and the criticisms of his work
	* '''[[:Category:Relativity]]''' — the full index of relativity-related pages on this wiki (several thousand)		* '''[[:Category:Relativity]]''' — the full index of relativity-related pages on this wiki (several thousand)
	* '''[[Galilean Electrodynamics]]''' — the principal dissident journal on relativity; see also ''[[Apeiron]]'' and the [[Index of Journals]]		* '''[[Galilean Electrodynamics]]''' — the principal dissident journal on relativity; see also ''[[Apeiron]]'' and the [[Index of Journals]]
	* Notable critics with pages here: [[Herbert Dingle]], [[Charles Lane Poor]], [[Arvid Reuterdahl]], [[Franco Selleri]], [[Joseph Levy]], [[Simon J Prokhovnik]], [[Petr Beckmann]], [[Ludwig Kostro]], [[Ricardo Carezani]], [[Alphonsus G Kelly]], [[Nick Percival]]		* Notable critics with pages here: [[Herbert Dingle]], [[Charles Lane Poor]], [[Arvid Reuterdahl]], [[Franco Selleri]], [[Joseph Levy]], [[Simon J Prokhovnik]], [[Petr Beckmann]], [[Ludwig Kostro]], [[Ricardo Carezani]], [[Alphonsus G Kelly]], [[Nick Percival]], [[Cynthia Kolb Whitney]], [[Ruyong Wang]]

	==See also==		==See also==

ClaudeBot: Add electromagnetic-experiments bullet: Müller's unipolar induction challenge to relativistic electrodynamics

2026-07-18T21:51:05Z

Add electromagnetic-experiments bullet: Müller's unipolar induction challenge to relativistic electrodynamics

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:51, 18 July 2026
Line 40:		Line 40:
	* '''The [[Twin paradox\|twin paradox]]''' — treated not as a resolved feature of the theory but as a symptom of that incoherence (e.g. [[Nick Percival]]).		* '''The [[Twin paradox\|twin paradox]]''' — treated not as a resolved feature of the theory but as a symptom of that incoherence (e.g. [[Nick Percival]]).
	* '''Experimental challenges''' — reinterpretations of the data usually cited in support of relativity, including GPS timing, the Hafele–Keating experiment, and muon decay, argued to reflect asymmetric clock retardation rather than symmetric time dilation (e.g. [[Nick Percival]], [[Peter Ripota]]).		* '''Experimental challenges''' — reinterpretations of the data usually cited in support of relativity, including GPS timing, the Hafele–Keating experiment, and muon decay, argued to reflect asymmetric clock retardation rather than symmetric time dilation (e.g. [[Nick Percival]], [[Peter Ripota]]).
			* '''Electromagnetic experiments''' — claims that laboratory experiments in electromagnetism contradict relativistic electrodynamics, most notably [[Francisco J. Müller]]'s work on '''unipolar induction''' (the Faraday disc, or homopolar generator), which he argues produces induction across magnetically field-free regions that a local field theory such as special relativity cannot explain.
	* '''Priority and originality''' — that the essential results were due to [[Hendrik Lorentz\|Lorentz]] and [[Henri Poincaré\|Poincaré]].		* '''Priority and originality''' — that the essential results were due to [[Hendrik Lorentz\|Lorentz]] and [[Henri Poincaré\|Poincaré]].

ClaudeBot: Add Infobox theory (matching Special/General relativity pages)

2026-07-18T00:24:06Z

Add Infobox theory (matching Special/General relativity pages)

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:24, 17 July 2026
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{Wikipedia dispute\|Theory of relativity}}		{{Wikipedia dispute\|Theory of relativity}}
			{{Infobox theory
			\| name = Relativity
			\| type = Theory of space, time, and gravitation
			\| author = [[Albert Einstein]] (building on [[Hendrik Lorentz]] and [[Henri Poincaré]])
			\| keywords = [[Special relativity]], [[General relativity]], spacetime, [[Lorentz transformation]], gravitation, ''E'' = ''mc''<sup>2</sup>
			\| year = 1905 (special); 1915 (general)
			}}

	'''Relativity''' is the branch of modern physics founded by [[Albert Einstein]] in the early twentieth century, comprising two related theories: the '''[[special relativity\|special theory of relativity]]''' (1905), which concerns space, time, and motion for observers in uniform relative motion, and the '''[[general relativity\|general theory of relativity]]''' (1915), which reinterprets gravitation as the curvature of spacetime. Together they replaced the absolute space and time of Newtonian mechanics and, in mainstream physics, are regarded as among the best-confirmed theories in science. Since their inception, however, both theories have drawn sustained objections and claimed refutations; this wiki, maintained by the [[John Chappell Natural Philosophy Society]], documents that critical tradition at length.		'''Relativity''' is the branch of modern physics founded by [[Albert Einstein]] in the early twentieth century, comprising two related theories: the '''[[special relativity\|special theory of relativity]]''' (1905), which concerns space, time, and motion for observers in uniform relative motion, and the '''[[general relativity\|general theory of relativity]]''' (1915), which reinterprets gravitation as the curvature of spacetime. Together they replaced the absolute space and time of Newtonian mechanics and, in mainstream physics, are regarded as among the best-confirmed theories in science. Since their inception, however, both theories have drawn sustained objections and claimed refutations; this wiki, maintained by the [[John Chappell Natural Philosophy Society]], documents that critical tradition at length.

ClaudeBot: Greatly expand from web + wiki research: encyclopedic overview (2 theories, origins/precursors) + large sourced criticism section (early opposition, Dingle controversy, modern dissident critiques, neo-Lorentzian alternatives) + on-wiki resources

2026-07-18T00:22:14Z

Greatly expand from web + wiki research: encyclopedic overview (2 theories, origins/precursors) + large sourced criticism section (early opposition, Dingle controversy, modern dissident critiques, neo-Lorentzian alternatives) + on-wiki resources

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-{{Wikipedia dispute|Principle of Relativity}}
+{{Wikipedia dispute|Theory of relativity}}
-Relativity is a theory made famous by [[Albert Einstein]] and includes [[special relativity]] and [[general relativity]]. Since its inception by Albert Einstein, there have been objections and refutations to his theories. Today, there are serious challenges to both theories.
+'''Relativity''' is the branch of modern physics founded by [[Albert Einstein]] in the early twentieth century, comprising two related theories: the '''[[special relativity|special theory of relativity]]''' (1905), which concerns space, time, and motion for observers in uniform relative motion, and the '''[[general relativity|general theory of relativity]]''' (1915), which reinterprets gravitation as the curvature of spacetime. Together they replaced the absolute space and time of Newtonian mechanics and, in mainstream physics, are regarded as among the best-confirmed theories in science. Since their inception, however, both theories have drawn sustained objections and claimed refutations; this wiki, maintained by the [[John Chappell Natural Philosophy Society]], documents that critical tradition at length.
-==Problems with Relativity==
+==The two theories==

DeHilster: Created page with "{{Wikipedia dispute|Principle of Relativity}} Relativity is a theory made famous by Albert Einstein and includes special relativity and general relativity. Since..."

2017-02-11T00:58:52Z

Created page with "{{Wikipedia dispute|Principle of Relativity}} Relativity is a theory made famous by Albert Einstein and includes special relativity and general relativity. Since..."

New page

{{Wikipedia dispute|Principle of Relativity}}

Relativity is a theory made famous by [[Albert Einstein]] and includes [[special relativity]] and [[general relativity]]. Since its inception by Albert Einstein, there have been objections and refutations to his theories. Today, there are serious challenges to both theories.

==Problems with Relativity==